Small, easy tutorial that explains the basics of the server, while the cave gives some style.
I discovered a bug with the recipe thing, where rightcliking the NPC with the map causes it to become a filled map instead of using the recipe... You should fix that if possible.
Other than the bug I discovered is the tutorial with its interactive examples a really nice way to get the players used to your servers mechanics.
Instead of preventing someone from entering a area (talking about the PvP explanation), why not prevent them from entering with barrier blocks? You seem to have used them previously, so why not there?
The spawn after you finished the tutorial is simple yet good.
The setup of the plugins is well done.
One thing that is a bit bad tho is that you level up quite fast in the herbalism skill... Not even 5 minutes played and I already was well over level 15 from just destroying grass and a few flowers, so perhaps tweek it a bit.
I didn't quite understand the system behind those mystical chests that you can find. Rightclicking them starts a sort of countdown before you get the item that is already shown inside them? Why not just directly give the item or why not keep it a mystery so that the "Searching..." part makes more sense?
The chat has a simple design, even considering that you can get prefixes/suffixes with icons/emojis.
Having an option to disable the scoreboard when needed is a nice thing to have, even tho the scoreboard isn't that extreme.
Another downside is the previously mentioned bug, so I won't go into detail here.
Average Rating: 7.666...
Final Rating: 8/10 [Really Good]
The design is decent.
The halloween-theme is not bad and I actually like it. Only complain is, that the cobwebs are a bit much tho. Maybe reduce it a bit.
Maybe add some eastereggs, for people that actively explore the spawn?
You could also add some armorstands, to make it a bit more "alive".
Good and decent use of holograms,.
Why blocking /help? Instead of blocking it, you could easly override and customize it.
You should reduce the clear-message. It shouldn't appear 3 times in chat.
/[tab] is blocked and /pl only shows custom stuff. That's good.
I tested the custom island. Looks decent.
You should try to reduce/disable the crate-message, when someone finds a crate,,, The spam is annoying.
Island plugin works nice and the addition of the custom ore generator is also not bad.
Yet it is still SkyBlock, so there is honestly not that much you could make wrong.
Tablist is ok. It isn't overloaded with unwanted information.
Final Rating: 8/10 [Really good]
This isn't directly server-related, but more a thing you should change at yourself.
Nice decoration of the spawn to show what you offer on the server.
After the completion of the tutorial did I watch in the oposite direction of the hologram (it was behind me.... Intended?)
The spawn is really well made.
It offers some good details and the use of NPCs makes it more alive.
Small things like the "missing" signs about a owner being missed are small things that makes it unique.
A good use of /help.
The Tablist looks simple and is easy to read. I like that.
The menus are easy and show everything needed.
You should disable the WorldGuard messages with "/rg [region] flag deny-message -e"
Average Rating: 8.333...
Final Rating: 8 [Really good]
I make simple reviews about servers.
To learn more about how I rate the servers, check the Rating-System page!